The second week of SurKshetra introduced the jury of
the show to the world. Contestants from both countries performed in
front of the jury. Even though there weren’t any points given this week,
the contestants were introduced to the jury as well as the captains of
both teams.
There is a lot to write about since the world buzzing about
the episodes this week and everyone is tweeting, blogging and posting
about it on different platforms. One unanimous feedback coming our way
is that everyone loved Atif Aslam’s rendition of "Dilbar Merey” followed
by a duet with Asha Bhosle, singing "Chura Liya”. We are very proud of
our superstar and his performance this week. It wasn’t long ago that
these reality shows intentionally attacked Atif and his success. Atif,
as always, kept quiet and focused on his work. Through his hard work,
dedication and the blessings of Allah, he is now a prominent member of a
singing competition himself and has been given the power to have an
opinion. However, unlike other members of the show, Atif isn’t misusing
the power and authority that has been given to him. The world of social
media has been quite active this week and people are clearly sensing
favoritism and bias on the jury panel. Even Indian music lovers who have
watched the show with a practical approach have been commenting on the
bias that is being shown towards the Indian contestants by a particular
jury member. Atif Aslam respects the musical legends of India, he has
always respected them. In fact the first song he ever hummed was by
Kishore Kumar and he often mentions it in his interviews. However, it is
only fair to treat every contestant equally, whether it’s the points or
the comments. There were many instances this week where Pakistani
contestants were being treated differently as opposed to the Indian
contestants. Pakistani contestants were being advised to sing softly
while Indian contestants singing high pitch were being given a standing
ovation. One Pakistani contestant was rightfully advised to work on his
dialect and pronunciation; it was a very good advice. However, when an
Indian contestant was advised the same by a jury member, another jury
member stated that pronunciation isn’t that important nowadays so that
mistake is forgiven. The same jury member kept quiet when the Pakistani
contestant was being advised the same. These small instances will add up
to a lot when accumulated. It doesn’t make sense if one Pakistani
contestant is appreciated for his hard work while the others are
subjected to criticism for things that are being blatantly ignored for
the Indian contestants. Atif asks a question to the other captain or
makes a statement about the other captain but the reply, the response
comes from a different source. We were not going to post anything about
all this; we didn’t feel it was necessary to talk about favoritism and
bias. However, the feedback from the people watching the show from both
countries has encouraged us, motivated us to write about it. We are
proud of the sensible viewership of the show and we appreciate the fact
that these actions are being pointed out to us. People are being vocal
about it. In fact we are pleasantly surprised that the viewers have
picked up on these things so early. Legends of the industry will always
be respected by Atif Aslam but when it comes to fairness, he will not
compromise the ability and hard work of his team and won’t be afraid to
speak his mind about it.
Atif has repeatedly mentioned that this is not a war for him,
it is a message of peace and love, a healthy competition played in the
right spirit from his side. But it doesn’t mean that anything goes. Any
competition has certain rules and guidelines and we can only enjoy the
competition if these rules and guidelines are followed in each case, not
just selective rulings. Atif’s approach of peace and love doesn’t mean
that he will let anyone be unfair to his team. It also doesn’t mean that
he will be disrespectful to anyone unlike other members on the show. He
will always be respectful and polite in his approach but won’t hold
back about what he feels. Hence, his positive and friendly approach
should not be mistaken for a complacent captain.
The coming week will bring different point of views from both
captains in terms of the judgment and there will surely be some
fireworks on the show. We will keep all the Aadeez updated about the
happenings of the week with another blog next week. We will simply share
our point of view and Atif’s point of view from the episode; we feel it
is quite simple and logical. As simple as the logic Atif had about the
backup vocals but even that issue was complicated by others. Anyway, see
you next week.
|